Hi Everyone. Well, after 15 years the RV-Dreams Community Forum is coming to an end. Since it began in August 2005, we've had 58 Million page views, 124,000 posts, and we've spent about $15,000 to keep this valuable resource for RVers free and open. But since we are now off the road and have settled down for the next chapter of our lives, we are taking the Forum down effective June 30, 2021. It has been a tough decision, but it is now time.
We want to thank all of our members for their participation and input over the years, and we want to especially thank those that have acted as Moderators for us during our amazing journey living and traveling in our RV and growing the RV-Dreams Family. We will be forever proud to have been founders of this Forum and to have been supported by such a wonderful community. Thank you all!!
Maybe somebody can lend some info to this.. Posted this elsewhere, as well.
Ordered a DRV w/ the Winguard SK-swm3 on top.. Went today to get the boxes sent to RV4LESS.. Not that easy !
DirectTV sent me to a company KVH.. Kvh says Directv is nuts.. Called Dealer, who said to call Winguard..
Spoke to wineguard.. They can set up a MOBILE directv account.. $92 / mo premier , $24/ mo 4 boxes, Dvr $15 = $131 / mo FIRST YEAR ONLY. Second year goes to $129 for service + $39 rentals = $168 / mo. 2 years = 3588 Damn..
As a RESIDENTIAL customer it is $92 / mo.. free boxes , free dvr. 2 years= $2208
So residential is a savings of $1380 for 2 years..
It is legal for you to have the unit installed in a house, and use it in your RV.. They told me that.
I'm on a 5 year adventure..budget. so savings for 5 years is $3450 ! Thats alot of money for TV savings, where I come from.. They really screw over the RV community.. I wish I had looked into this before buying the roof mounted receiver..
I'm wondering if I can find a installer to just "hook me up" As residential ? Winguard can not do residential.. only mobile.
Or do I break any laws if I have it installed at a house, and move it to the RV? Some are saying they can now tell where you are receiving from?
Thanks
Steve
ps.. another piece of the puzzle that just seems hard to me.. does it ever end?
__________________
"Be who you are and say what you feel because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind" - Dr. Seuss
Steve, for the first two years all I did was move the two house receivers, (both HD DVR) to the RV. Once the RV is set up you just push the button to raise the Winegard Slimline and it locks onto all the satellites for the same selections I have in the house. Two independent HD DVR's just like in the big house.
About a year ago I had WI-FI installed in my big house and some SWM features including the SWM LNB. This now requires me to change the antennae type in settings when swapping from one location to the other. No big deal at all, and I still get all the channels as if I were in the big house.
Yours may not be that simple since you said you had a SWM antennae, there are additional boxes/splitters required with a SWM system. Good luck.
FYI: in 3.5 years, only twice was the antennae, mounted on top of the fifth wheel, not been able to get all the Direct TV stations.
I don't feel I'm abusing any regulations since we're paying for using the Direct TV service either at the big house or the little house, not both.
__________________
CK PK 2011 Ford F 350 Dually 2011 Carriage Cameo 37CKSLS Retired early 2011
Most RV parks I've researched offer free cable (or maybe $1/day for cable) and free WiFi. Unless you are planning on boondocking a lot and must have Sat TV at all costs, as free over-the-air broadcast TV (antenna based) providing local news and weather won't do, and you-re willing to pay then go for it. This is not within my meager FT budget. TThough I do enjoy direct TV now (at about $75/mo.) I will have to forgo this extravagence for the lifestyle I desire.
Chip
__________________
1999 National Tropical Class A gasser
Toad - 2.4l Chevy Cobalt SS with 400k miles and counting.
TV is a big part of our life too...but I am hoping it is much less so when we get out on the road. The problem is all our favorite shows are on HBO and Showtime and to get those Chanel's you have to go premium packages. It's a real shame HBO go and Showtime Go ( which I use when traveling all the time and work great) are not available as standalone services. Anyways we are talking through all the options including downloading shows or renting and sticking with the basic. Haven't worked it all out yet but for some folks (ourselves included) at least starting out this is a big decision point.
One option we are kicking around is not having satellite TV at all, and directing the funds or a portion of it toward buying additional bandwidth on our internet service. $80 dollars of Satellite service buys an extra 16GB on Verizon with an existing 4GB share plan or 20GB for $90 a month from Millenicom. IF we already had 20GB of data budgeted, we'd now have at least 40GB/month... that's a lot of video, etc. Yeah we would miss live events, but some local TV over the air might be available , the rest could be streamed.(depending local reception) My current work schedule has me in bed before some of my favs come on TV but with On Demand(comcast) or netflix etc I can watch them at my leisure when I want. By watching the stuff I want this way, I avoid the mindless plunking myself on the couch and just endure whatever is on. I also find I'm getting more things done with my new free time. Just a thought. Everybody has different viewing needs
FWIW, Brian
-- Edited by biggaRView on Sunday 27th of July 2014 01:05:32 PM
Steve, we use the portable sat dish. We can park under trees in summer and get satellite. We do use Dish. We get more tv than we need. $79.00 monthly. With the portables we are limited on boxes, no recording. We bought our own DVR and use it. Cheaper that way too.
-- Edited by Glenn West on Sunday 27th of July 2014 12:01:56 PM
__________________
2003 Teton Grand Freedon 2006 Mobile Suites 32TK3 SOLD 2006 Freightliner Century 120 with Detroit 14L singled, ultrashift, hauling a 2016 Smart Passion
Bill, I didn't say it was for everyone. Not even sure is it right for us. We are not big TV watchers these days anyway, some vids and some streaming music now, mostly browsing, downloading books, and email and we are between 7GB and 20GB, that leaves some room for a few movies and TV shows just on the data we would be paying for. Add in some CG wifi, libraries here and there etc. and for now it seems we could be just fine. This particular "pie" is only half baked at this point and a lot could change by the time we hit the road. We already have an extensive music collection stored digitally, and more than a few movies & books also thanks to unlimited internet here at our S&B. Use it while we have it.
I also hear you on 40GB, it could easily get burned through in any given month. As an example, when we signed up for Amazon Prime, I watched/streamed over 200 episodes of Stargate SG1(yeah I'm a junkie) in less than a month, then we streamed 2 dozen movies and the first 3 seasons of Downton Abbey in the second month before season 4 was aired on PBS. I wish I had paid attention to that data usage... it had to be high and obviously I couldn't do that in the scenario I'm suggesting. For not being heavy TV users... we binged on the newness of Amazon Prime, we have since settled back to our usual routine.
Sorry, Terry, did not mean to stray off the Direct TV angle of the thread... Just offering some outside the box thinking to the discussion as an option.
-- Edited by biggaRView on Sunday 27th of July 2014 02:37:28 PM
Just want to respond to the roof top Direct TV seeing through trees, this is not true. We are frequently in a site that we get little (one sat) or none. It doesn't take a lot of limbs in the way to make a big difference either. For us, this is not a problem for just a couple of days. However it would be a problem if we were set up for a month or more. The only time we were having an issue with trees and we were set up for a month we could still get sat 101 so we could get the SD stations with Direct TV so it was OK. We don't carry a tripod/dish yet and we have been FT for 2 years now. I guess TV is not a real big deal to us, but we also have most of the time been able to get either Direct TV or OTA TV with the batwing. The very few times we haven't been able to get any TV we just did something else for a day or two.
__________________
Full Time Since August 4, 2012
2008 F-450 King Ranch 4x4 crew cab DRW
2013 Sanibel 3500 5er
Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans.
RVs For Less installed the dish and I called the 800 number for Directv and scheduled a regular install appointment. Directv shows my service address as the RVs For Less address but they show my PO box as my mailing address. This seems to have worked well so far. I am thinking about changing my address to my daughter's in Denver hoping that would always get me the Denver local stations. That way I'd get the all the Broncos games ;>)....just doing some more research to make sure there are no problems in doing so.
Directv had trouble finding the right coax connected to the Traveler so they put a dish on the fence to get it working (no additional cost). RVs For Less then connected it to the Traveler and I kept the other dish for my portable.
It is not illegal to take a Direct TV receiver from you home or fixed address and use it in the RV. Direct TV could care less.
The “illegal” issue concerns getting the networks (CBS, ABC, Fox, etc.) direct from satellite ALL over the United States, not just the local stations.IF you want network service (called Direct Network Service or DNS for short) you must sign some papers that say the receiver / antenna is ONLY used in the RV. The form is on the Direct TV site.This is an FCC, government requirement. (Why is not the issue – it’s the law.) You may not have DNS at a fixed (home / building) location.This has nothing to do with getting the local channels from a particular area via satellite.The illegal part is putting a receiver with DNS at a fixed, non-mobile location.
If you want DNS so you can get CBS, ABC, Fox, etc. network service throughout the 48 states go here:
Fill out the form and follow the instructions.This is the form necessary for DNS in addition to your regular Direct TV service.Do this AFTER you have regular Direct TV service working.
As pertains to getting a signal when there are trees:With the Winegard Trav’ler antenna you can manually tell it to only seek satellite # 101. (It’s in the manual to change from multi-satellite to manual - one satellite seeking.) The 101 satellite has everything on it programming wise but only in Standard Definition.The High Definition comes from satellites 99 and 103.Now, it can find the 101 satellite a lot easier than the other two satellites 99 and 103.But when it does find 101 many many times 99 and 103 will come in as well as they are so physically close.“It depends.” Works for me 95% of the time and I’ve been doing this a very long time.
Anyone interested in more details of this might like to do a search for Direct TV or satellite TV.There have been numerous threads that have outlined much of this over the years in detail.
Direct TV works extremely well on the road and is the most flexible system for RV use due to needing only one satellite to get programming albeit in SD and the fact the HD satellites are so close to the SD bird. The installation for a Travl’er SWM-3 to Direct TV receiver is one cable simple to each receiver.When asked I recommend the HR-24 (or HR-23) DVR receivers.They boot quickly and are the least complicated to install with the single wire requirement from the antenna to the receiver.
My mother-in-law just had an interesting experience with her new motorhome, a Winnebago Sightseer. It came with HDMI as the only TV connection. That meant she needed an HDMI DirecTV DVR, which is designed for HD. But her dish on the roof was SD, not HD, and the house DirecTV service was also SD. It took extra time and effort to get a waiver to use the HD DVR just for SD.
__________________
Bill Joyce, 40' 2004 Dutch Star DP towing an AWD 2020 Ford Escape Hybrid Journal at http://www.sacnoth.com Full-timing since July 2003
My mother-in-law just had an interesting experience with her new motorhome, a Winnebago Sightseer. It came with HDMI as the only TV connection. That meant she needed an HDMI DirecTV DVR, which is designed for HD. But her dish on the roof was SD, not HD, and the house DirecTV service was also SD. It took extra time and effort to get a waiver to use the HD DVR just for SD.
Bill:
Thanks interesting.I run the HD DVR on an 18” antenna with SD reception all the time in really bad places with obstructions.Are you saying it was difficult to get the HD DRV initially authorized without the two HD birds?Or was it that you didn’t (I wouldn’t either) want to pay the extra for HD that couldn’t receive or enjoy. (There can be some guide data download issues when you can't see all the birds for extended periods of time.)
My mother-in-law just had an interesting experience with her new motorhome, a Winnebago Sightseer. It came with HDMI as the only TV connection. That meant she needed an HDMI DirecTV DVR, which is designed for HD. But her dish on the roof was SD, not HD, and the house DirecTV service was also SD. It took extra time and effort to get a waiver to use the HD DVR just for SD.
Bill:
Thanks interesting.I run the HD DVR on an 18” antenna with SD reception all the time in really bad places with obstructions.Are you saying it was difficult to get the HD DRV initially authorized without the two HD birds?Or was it that you didn’t (I wouldn’t either) want to pay the extra for HD that couldn’t receive or enjoy. (There can be some guide data download issues when you can't see all the birds for extended periods of time.)
Just curious as to the exact snag.
Thanks
DirecTV would not authorize the HD DVR without HD service in the house, which is actually my sister-in-law's house. Neither the RV or house has an HD dish, so paying extra for something they could not use was a sticking point. The DVR is working fine recording SD and they did provide a waiver from DirecTVs policy of HDMI receivers and DVRs only working with HD service. My mother-in-law blames La Mesa RV for the mess, since they installed the SD only automatic dish and blamed her existing DVR for being "too old". An independent RV tech figured out they needed HDMI, so we wonder how La Mesa tested the dish? DirecTV tried to send the DVR to the house first, since the house needed to be upgraded first. La Mesa stopped taking her phone calls, since they did not want to pay to replace her SD dish with HD. A total mess.
I understand why Winnebago went with HDMI wiring, it saved them money, but the dealer and RV tech had not seen it come from the factory before.
-- Edited by bjoyce on Thursday 31st of July 2014 07:55:12 PM
-- Edited by bjoyce on Thursday 31st of July 2014 07:58:23 PM
__________________
Bill Joyce, 40' 2004 Dutch Star DP towing an AWD 2020 Ford Escape Hybrid Journal at http://www.sacnoth.com Full-timing since July 2003
My mother-in-law just had an interesting experience with her new motorhome, a Winnebago Sightseer. It came with HDMI as the only TV connection. That meant she needed an HDMI DirecTV DVR, which is designed for HD. But her dish on the roof was SD, not HD, and the house DirecTV service was also SD. It took extra time and effort to get a waiver to use the HD DVR just for SD.
Bill:
Thanks interesting.I run the HD DVR on an 18” antenna with SD reception all the time in really bad places with obstructions.Are you saying it was difficult to get the HD DRV initially authorized without the two HD birds?Or was it that you didn’t (I wouldn’t either) want to pay the extra for HD that couldn’t receive or enjoy. (There can be some guide data download issues when you can't see all the birds for extended periods of time.)
Just curious as to the exact snag.
Thanks
DirecTV would not authorize the HD DVR without HD service in the house, which is actually my sister-in-law's house. Neither the RV or house has an HD dish, so paying extra for something they could not use was a sticking point. The DVR is working fine recording SD and they did provide a waiver from DirecTVs policy of HDMI receivers and DVRs only working with HD service. My mother-in-law blames La Mesa RV for the mess, since they installed the SD only automatic dish and blamed her existing DVR for being "too old". An independent RV tech figured out they needed HDMI, so we wonder how La Mesa tested the dish? DirecTV tried to send the DVR to the house first, since the house needed to be upgraded first. La Mesa stopped taking her phone calls, since they did not want to pay to replace her SD dish with HD. A total mess.
I understand why Winnebago went with HDMI wiring, it saved them money, but the dealer and RV tech had not seen it come from the factory before.
-- Edited by bjoyce on Thursday 31st of July 2014 07:55:12 PM
-- Edited by bjoyce on Thursday 31st of July 2014 07:58:23 PM
Bill, thanks for the clarification.That’s as I thought it would be but wanted to make sure.Seems I've read other reports about the RV dealer you mentioned – none good.I agree, doubt they actually tested the complete antenna system.Few RV dealers and OEMs really understand TV / entertainment systems.They are an afterthought.Some do, but a very few based on the number of times I’ve had to rewire people’s rigs so they work as designed.
As for the HDMI only wiring – yes, I hate to say it but it’s time to move on from composite and component cables as well as “stereo” audio cables. So I do understand why RV OEMs would move in this direction. I actually have a TV set that only has an HDMI input. That’s it.