It's been awhile (last summer!) since I introduced myself and posted a couple times. Since then, the house sold (quickly) and, after taking care of family matters, we've been short-term-renting. RV research was temporarily suspended, but now, we're back at it with gusto! I've continued to lurk on several forums, but I've got to say that I return to RV-Dreams because of the LACK of hysterics, feuding, and "mine's bigger than yours." Thank you all.
My question(s): What is your (recent) experience with obtaining info from RV Consumer Group -- and/or -- from JR Consumer Resources?
Money well spent? Another supplement for narrowing down the list? A worthwhile companion to shows, chats with owners, and forum reading? Would you choose one over the other, and why?
Not wanting to be penny-wise and pound-foolish, I'm inclined to believe that it's a small price that may save thousands -- and headaches -- when it comes time to purchase. Thanks much.
Barbaraok said
11:00 AM Feb 15, 2015
First question to ask yourself, do the people who run those site RV? I know that couple that runs RV Consumer Group doesn't. So why would you pay for information from people who don't RV?
Lots of research, narrow down to a couple of specific manufactures and models, then go to the owners section on iRV2.net and ask what owners like and dislike about the rigs. Best info we got when looking.
Barb
Terry and Jo said
12:06 PM Feb 15, 2015
Barbara gives good advice. Also, when researching specific brands, look online to see if there are separate owner's groups for those brands. See if they have forums available there as well. However, when reading any forum, keep in mind that they will "attract" people that are looking for the solution to a problem, thus, they may give the appearance that the specific brand isn't good quality. When reading issues involving problems, are those problems related to the actual RV or to "components" manufactured by other companies to be used in the RV. For instance, refrigerators, a/c units, hot water heaters are all separate manufacturers from the RV company and any problems with those components shouldn't be used to judge the quality of the overall RV.
Terry
alternativeview said
01:02 PM Feb 15, 2015
"So why would you pay for information from people who don't RV?"
Barbara, this is a point well taken. We have learned so much from scouring the forums, crawling under rigs at shows, comparing specs, asking questions (inluding of rv'ers at shows, who often have much more insight than the salespeople), etc. Sounds like you recommend just keeping at it, digging deeper, narrowing down the list, and letting our diligence be our guide. Thanks!
alternativeview said
01:12 PM Feb 15, 2015
Terry, I think you're spot on. I appreciate your reminder to separate the complaints and issues of the actual RV and other manufacturers' components. It also seems like unhappy people often vent on forums, whereas happy people are too busy enjoying their rigs and adventures to sing praises, so that tilts the scale, too. We were somewhat surprised at some of the "private" owners' forums, and that's definitely food for thought. And we were additionally surprised at how many sales staff, at shows and at dealerships, did NOT own an RV or even a tent. What the heck?
bjoyce said
02:08 PM Feb 15, 2015
Two points: The Gallants who run RV Consumer Group did RV in the past and he sold RVs, which gave him the idea to start the group. I know, a friend bought a trailer from him as a salesman and kept in contact. I also know the Gallants had a bus conversion for a while, but do not know if they had any other RVs and how long they have been RV less. Point 2 is watch what you say on iRV2, especially if you can't understand why no one has mentioned something that you thought was well known about a product. They give all of their moderators a lot of power and any can and some will ban you from the entire site. Some moderators have biases and do not like alternate views, and some work for companies and do not allow any positive messages about their competitors or negatives on their own products. Most moderators are good, but some are not and it does not matter if you are banned. I just let Google find me the messages to read, because if I was banned I could not read those messages.
alternativeview said
03:24 PM Feb 15, 2015
Bill, about the additional info regarding the Gallants, as well as your second point about commenting carefully on the irv2 boards -- thanks for the heads up. Indeed, Google can be a good friend!
It's been awhile (last summer!) since I introduced myself and posted a couple times. Since then, the house sold (quickly) and, after taking care of family matters, we've been short-term-renting. RV research was temporarily suspended, but now, we're back at it with gusto! I've continued to lurk on several forums, but I've got to say that I return to RV-Dreams because of the LACK of hysterics, feuding, and "mine's bigger than yours." Thank you all.
My question(s): What is your (recent) experience with obtaining info from RV Consumer Group -- and/or -- from JR Consumer Resources?
Money well spent? Another supplement for narrowing down the list? A worthwhile companion to shows, chats with owners, and forum reading? Would you choose one over the other, and why?
Not wanting to be penny-wise and pound-foolish, I'm inclined to believe that it's a small price that may save thousands -- and headaches -- when it comes time to purchase. Thanks much.
Lots of research, narrow down to a couple of specific manufactures and models, then go to the owners section on iRV2.net and ask what owners like and dislike about the rigs. Best info we got when looking.
Barb
Barbara gives good advice. Also, when researching specific brands, look online to see if there are separate owner's groups for those brands. See if they have forums available there as well. However, when reading any forum, keep in mind that they will "attract" people that are looking for the solution to a problem, thus, they may give the appearance that the specific brand isn't good quality. When reading issues involving problems, are those problems related to the actual RV or to "components" manufactured by other companies to be used in the RV. For instance, refrigerators, a/c units, hot water heaters are all separate manufacturers from the RV company and any problems with those components shouldn't be used to judge the quality of the overall RV.
Terry
"So why would you pay for information from people who don't RV?"
Barbara, this is a point well taken. We have learned so much from scouring the forums, crawling under rigs at shows, comparing specs, asking questions (inluding of rv'ers at shows, who often have much more insight than the salespeople), etc. Sounds like you recommend just keeping at it, digging deeper, narrowing down the list, and letting our diligence be our guide. Thanks!
Terry, I think you're spot on. I appreciate your reminder to separate the complaints and issues of the actual RV and other manufacturers' components. It also seems like unhappy people often vent on forums, whereas happy people are too busy enjoying their rigs and adventures to sing praises, so that tilts the scale, too. We were somewhat surprised at some of the "private" owners' forums, and that's definitely food for thought. And we were additionally surprised at how many sales staff, at shows and at dealerships, did NOT own an RV or even a tent. What the heck?
Bill, about the additional info regarding the Gallants, as well as your second point about commenting carefully on the irv2 boards -- thanks for the heads up. Indeed, Google can be a good friend!